Skip to content
The front entrance of Amore Mio on Crawfordsville Road

Benvenuti ad Amore Mio

Italian Subs & Espresso Bar in Indianapolis

Fresh ciabatta, real espresso, and a seat waiting for you.

Signature Ciabatta

Our house subs, named for the Italian cities that inspired them.

Roma ciabatta sandwich

Roma

Prosciutto di Parma, creamy burrata and our signature peach spread, layered with French arugula.

Half$9.50Whole$15.50
Florence ciabatta sandwich

Florence

Delicate pistachio mortadella with rich burrata, baby arugula and a hint of fig spread for a touch of Tuscan sweetness.

Half$9.75Whole$14.75
Sicilia ciabatta sandwich

Sicilia

Sopressata salami and hot capocollo layered with fresh mozzarella, fragrant basil pesto and fresh arugula. Rustic and hearty.

Half$9.50Whole$15.50
Hand-drawn coffee mural on the café wall

The Espresso Bar

From a quick espresso to an iced tiramisu latte, there's a cup for every kind of day.

  • CappuccinoS$5.72M$6.45L$6.95
  • Caramel MacchiatoS$5.72M$6.45L$6.95
  • Iced Tiramisu Latte$6.95
  • Affogato$5.95
Full coffee menu
Best of 2025 Italian Restaurant plaque awarded to Amore Mio Italian Subs and Espresso Bar
Top Rated in Indianapolis

A Local Favorite, Fast.

Since opening our doors, the Indianapolis community has welcomed us with open arms. Thanks to your incredible support, we've become one of the city's highest-rated Italian spots on Google.

5.0 Stars

Google Average

Indy's Best

Italian Café

What Our Customers Say

Don't just take our word for it. Here's what our beloved customers have to say about their experience at Amore Mio

Rated 5 out of 5

“It's a recent new restaurant shop, and sandwiches are absolutely delicious! Nothing like anything I've ever tasted before! Staff are very fr…”

Luigi Moca
Rated 5 out of 5

“Super friendly staff. The sights and smells were amazing. I got the Sicilian sandwich. Absolutely delicious 😋 good long hours. Breakfast &…”

Jeff Johnston
Rated 5 out of 5

“I tried the Turkey & Pesto Panini (right) and the Sicilia (left) and these sandwiches were incredible! The Sicilia had this rich, savory aro…”

Ashley
A basket of fresh bread on a shelf with hanging plants inside the café

More Than Just Coffee

Experience the warmth of Italian hospitality in our rustic setting. Whether you're catching up with friends or finding a quiet moment for yourself, Amore Mio is your home away from home.

Stop By and Say Ciao!

Visit Us

Stop in for a fresh ciabatta and an espresso, or give us a call and we'll have your order ready.

Find us on Crawfordsville Road on Indy's west side, a quick drive from Clermont, Speedway, Brownsburg, Avon and Eagle Creek Park.

Amore Mio Italian Subs & Espresso Bar

9060 Crawfordsville Rd Suite 1
Indianapolis, IN 46234

Proudly serving Indianapolis' west side

  • Indianapolis
  • Clermont
  • Speedway
  • Brownsburg
  • Avon
  • Plainfield
  • Eagle Creek
  • Wayne Township
  • Pike Township
  • Hendricks County

Domande? Questions

Where is Amore Mio located?

Amore Mio Italian Subs & Espresso Bar is at 9060 Crawfordsville Rd Suite 1, Indianapolis, IN 46234, on Crawfordsville Road on the west side of Indianapolis, near Clermont, Speedway, Brownsburg and Avon.

What are Amore Mio’s hours?

We're open Mon - Thurs 10:00 AM - 5:00 PM; Fri 10:00 AM - 7:00 PM; Sat 9:00 AM - 7:00 PM; Sun 9:00 AM - 3:00 PM.

Do you offer carryout or delivery?

Yes. Order online through Toast for carryout or delivery, or call us at (317) 331-0891 and we'll have your order ready.

What kind of food does Amore Mio serve?

Italian subs on fresh ciabatta (like the Roma, Florence and Sicilia), panini, all-day breakfast, soups, salads, pizza, cheesecakes, tiramisu and a full espresso bar with cappuccinos, lattes, cold brew and refreshers.

Where do Amore Mio’s recipes come from?

Our recipes and traditions come from our family in Pescara, a city on the Adriatic coast in Italy’s Abruzzo region. We brought them to Indianapolis when we opened in 2025.

Do you serve breakfast all day?

Yes. Breakfast panini and our ham & cheese croissant are served all day, alongside espresso drinks from our bar.

Do you have meatless options?

Yes. Try the Venice ciabatta (mozzarella, tomato, basil pesto and arugula), the Caprese panini, or a Cheese, Margherita or Quattro Formaggi pizza.

Do I need a reservation?

No. Amore Mio is a walk-in café, so stop by any time we're open and grab a seat.

Which areas does Amore Mio serve?

We're on the west side of Indianapolis and welcome guests from Clermont, Speedway, Brownsburg, Avon, Plainfield, Eagle Creek, Wayne Township, Pike Township and Hendricks County.